Various tests for legal causation have been suggested but the Appellate Division has opted for a flexible umbrella criterion, which determines the closeness . A Q&A guide to the legal system in South Africa. On 16 May 2022, the Johannesburg Division of the High Court handed down a judgment, which explores the test for causation in determining whether the primary or special risks insurer was liable for . An act or circumstance that causes an event, where the event would not have happened had the act or circumstance not occurred. Wrongfulness Of Omissions. Legal theory is presented in light of the influence of the Bill of Rights, comparative perspectives, and . There must be both factual and legal causation. This is a criminal act that constitutes the conduct prohibited by the statute. The decision may be perceived as, at best, widening the approach when undertaking the 'but for' test, or at least providing much needed clarity . A cause that is legally sufficient to result in liability. Causation forms part of one of the five elements of a crime when determining if the accused is guilty or not. o Basic question: whether the is a close enough relationship between the wrongdoer's conduct and its consequences . The text addresses the general principles of criminal law, as well as the elements of specific common law crimes and statutory offences. In terms of white-collar offences, South Africa has a matrix of domestic legislation that caters for the particular offences that are associated with white-collar crime, which stands alongside the common law offences such as fraud. Introduction to Law and Legal Skills J. Barnard-Naude, L.J. Source: South African Criminal Law Reports, The (1990 to date)/CHRONOLOGICAL LISTING OF CASES . Politics A. Heywood. The majority of the Constitutional Court accepted that the common law contained rules (1) and (3).8 It denied that the common law contained rules (2) and (4). The Law of Delict in South Africa, second edition, provides a clear, concise and rigorous introduction to the general principles of delictual law. PVL3703 Law of Delict 2010 Mitzi Coertzen_SU1-13. An event that comes between the initial event (in a sequence of events) and the end result, thereby altering the natural . Slaves and Free Blacks met in the houses of Muslim exiles and on the hills around the town. View Legal Causation_ S v Tembani 2007 1 SACR 355 SCA (1).pdf from LAW 001 at University of Limpopo. The cornerstone of the law on causation is that the prosecution must show that the defendant's act was the substantial and operating cause of the harm. The High Court in Financial Conduct Authority v Arch Insurance (UK) Ltd [2020] EWHC 2448 (Comm) have provided much needed guidance on business interruption insurance.Within the judgment was analysis on the law of causation for insurance policies. R v Blaue [1975] 1 WLR 1411. . South Africans can now legally purchase, possess, and use up to 20 mg of CBD per day. Novus actus interveniens is a Latin legal phrase, which describes an important principle in criminal and civil procedure in as far as causation and liability is concerned. Criminal Law in South Africa, second edition, offers a clear, comprehensive and practical explanation of the principles of criminal law in South Africa. The Q&A gives a high-level overview of the key legal concepts including the constitution, system of governance and the general legislative process; the main sources of law; the court structure and hierarchy; the judiciary and its appointment; the general rules of civil and criminal litigation . . The term 'substantial' makes it clear that the defendant's act need not be the sole cause but the act must be more than just a de minimis or a slight contribution to the result. Ranchod J, in the Gauteng Division, Pretoria had occasion to deal with this principle in a third-party claim in this . Popular books for Law and Public Services . Examples of Breach of Duty that the defendant failed to act in line with that duty of care or "breached" the duty, that the plaintiff suffered damages and that these damages were caused by the defendant's breach of duty of care. Causation: factual causation and legal causation. The structure of the text supports . Global Politics A. Heywood. Denis Klimchuk, Causation, Thin Skulls and Equality (1998) at pg. In the recent case of Legal Aid South Africa v Jansen [2020] JOL 47984 (LAC), the Labour Appeal Court ("the LAC") was required to evaluate whether an employee's ("Jansen") dismissal was automatically unfair on account of his depression. Loubser (Ed), Midgley (Ed), Mukheiber, Niesing, Perumal The Law of Delict in South Africa 2ed (2012) NB: Students are advised to read the prescribed textbook together with J. Neethling & J.M. Medical Negligence - Nature of Causation, Damages and Compensation. the defendant's breach in fact resulted in the damage complained of ( factual causation) and. South Africa: Can delictual legal duties exist separately from contractual duties? PVL3703 Law of Delict 2010 Mitzi Coertzen_SU 21-32. Labour Lawyer in South Africa. law of delict causation factual causation introduction to causation both factual and legal causation are general requirements for delictual liability and are. Legal Aid South Africa v Jansen (CA3/2019) [2020] ZALAC 37 (21 July 2020) To succeed in a claim for automatically unfair dismissal based on disability, factual causation and legal causation must be established. Answer: Factual causation is the unbroken sequence of events that results in an outcome being caused by one or more (in)actions. Roman-Dutch law, based on Roman law, is the strongest influence on South Africa's common law, where delict also falls under the law of obligations.As has been pointed out, however, In contrast to the casuistic approach of the Roman law of delict, the South African law of delict is based [.] on three pillars: the actio legis . Mackay v Absa Group & another [1999] 12 BLLR 1317 (LC) The content of this website is for information purposes only. That premise was that the South African common law contained the four rules set out above. It is only relevant for consequence crimes, such as murder or arson, and there must be a causal link . BTEC Level 3 National Public Services Student Book D. Gray, T. Lilley. It asks whether the loss is too remote for the factual cause to also be the legal cause. The distinction is not generally overtly made in South Africa, but was alluded to in Siman & Co (Pty) Ltd v Barclays National Bank Ltd 1984 (2) SA 888 (A) at 915. . First, the defendant must be the factual or but for cause of the victim's harm. Practical Legal Skills R. Hyams, S. Campbell. Revisiting causation in South African insurance law in light of the national lockdown occasioned by the COVID-19 pandemic, and the effect on business interruption (BI) insurance. . GET THE MINI COURSE FOR $9 - https://go.thelawsimplified.com/FastTrackCriminalFor Private Tutoring: http://wa.me/94777037245Get Access to Courses & Webinars . Legal causation, on the other hand, involves considerations into, amongst others, reasonable . Siber Ink. 1. A flexible approach is accordingly suggested. 60 Riviera Road, Killarney, Johannesburg, South Africa. 344 2 1 2 Legal Causation The best-known recognised theories in respect of the determination of legal causation are the theory of adequate causation 23, the "direct consequences" theory 24, the theory of "fault" 25, reasonable foreseeability criterion 26 and the "flexible approach". Research Methods for Law M. McConville. Introduction. It entails the court asking if the accused's conduct caused the unlawful consequence. The rationale behind insurance is to protect oneself against the occurrence of undesirable risk. 1. The Constitutional Court in Mashongwa v Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa [2015], said: Seemingly the central interests that justify having an entry on causation in the law in a philosophy encyclopedia are: to understand just what is the law's concept of causation, if it has one; to see how that concept compares to the concept of causation is use in science and in everyday life; and to examine what reason(s) there are justifying or explaining whatever . The Supreme Court of Appeal recently considered the question of liability for emotional shock and resulting detectable psychiatric injury in the matter of Road Accident Fund v Sauls 2002 (2) SA 55 (SCA). He was accompanied by his fiance . Constitution of the Republic of South Africa 108 of 1996. PVL3703 Past paper. 84. explain the flexible approach to legal causation as applied by the courts, and be able to apply it o S v Mokgethi: Van Heerden-there is no single and general criterion for the legal causation which is applicable in all instances. Factual causation requires . Islam was brought to the Cape by Muslim political exiles and slaves from the East Indies. The test for factual causation is the sine qua non ( or "but for" ) test. The enquiry into legal causation usually follows factual causation. For the law to consider a product legal, the CBD must come from hemp plants. Integrating the common law, statutory law and constitutional perspectives, the text provides a rich contextual framework which supports understanding. . . Causation is a term used to refer to the relationship between a person's actions and the result of those actions. In determining factual causation, courts traditionally employ the well-known conditio sine qua non test as the point of departure for establishing a factual nexus (Visser 2006 TSAR 583-585 and 587; see also Du Plessis While circumstance crimes appear on the authority of Achterdam (Ball v. U.S., 163 U.S. 662, 16 S. Ct. 1192, 41 L. Ed. And these hemp plants must contain up to 0.2% THC by weight. One asks whether the claimant's harm would have occurred in any event without, (that is but-for) the defendant's conduct. Ltd. Downloaded: Mon Nov 18 2019 08:16:06 GMT+0200 (South Africa Standard Time) CAMERON JA (b) The gunshot wound was an indispensable precondition . PVL3703 law_of_delict_all_mcq. Introduction One notion a particular of the of main top-down version philosophical causation.1 of this concept, arguments In previous understanding in works discussion I have the today process supported is the in notion of top-down causation.1 In previous works I have supported. PVL3703 Past Resources. Associates: Sasha Kadish, Dean Brainin, Melani Scholtz, Tamaryn Nowitz & Abdul Buckus. PVL3703 law_of_delict_-_all_questions. The distinction is not generally overtly made in South Africa, but was alluded to in Siman & Co (Pty) Ltd v Barclays National Bank Ltd 1984 (2) . In a legal sense, causation is used to connect the dots between a person's actions, such as driving under the influence, and the result, such as an accident causing serious injuries. The Law of Contract in South Africa D. Hutchison, C. Pretorius. Keywords : code, information control, network, top-down causation.1. Legal Causation Loubser and Midgley (eds) Chapter 6 (89-100) Neethling and Potgieter Chapter 5 (197-219) S v Mokgethi 1990 (1) SA 39J-41B . 25 March 2022. 126. The Prevention and Combatting of Corrupt Activities Act 12 of 2004 (PRECCA), the Financial Intelligence Centre Act . As the Model Penal Code states, "[c]onduct is the cause of a result when(a) it is an antecedent but for which . Actus reus, or the guilty act. Hallett [1969] SASR 141. Principles of Evidence P.J. Code Ann. Sources. Actual causation is determined by literal cause and effect. PVL3703 Law of Delict 2010 Mitzi Coertzen_SU 14-20. PVL3703 past_paper_nov_2009. [21] Capacity. The South African case law . South African criminal law is the body of national law relating to crime in South Africa.In the definition of Van der Walt et al., a crime is "conduct which common or statute law prohibits and expressly or impliedly subjects to punishment remissible by the state alone and which the offender cannot avoid by his own act once he has been convicted." Crime involves the infliction of harm against . A's car rear ends B's car, resulting in damage to the back end of B's car. Delict in Roman law fell under the law of obligations. . Indemnity insurance is taken out to indemnify oneself against a loss. Roman-Dutch law, based on Roman law, is the strongest influence on South Africa's common law, where delict also falls under the law of obligations. Labour law rules! premise. Butterworths Company Law Handbook K. Walmsley. The Clements case concerned a motorcycle accident, . . "Causation" in Criminal Law is concerned with whether the defendant's conduct contributed sufficiently to the prohibited consequence to justify the criminal liability, which would be assessed from two aspects, namely "factual" and "legal" causation. Causation in Fact. A recent ruling by South Africa's Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) highlights the challenges unsuccessful tenderers for public contracts in the country face in raising successful claims for damages, even if the tender process was unlawful. Please note: Note the criticism of Nkabinde J (at para51) on blurring of the distinction between factual and legal causation. One asks whether the claimant's harm would have occurred in any event without, (that is but-for) the defendant's conduct. Under South African law, claims for damages are financial claims that are brought to compensate a plaintiff as a result of a loss-causing event that occurred because of the fault of the . R v Kennedy [2007] UKHL 38. For larceny in this case, the actus reus would be picking up Angry Agnes' phone . Legal causation is used to limit any liability to those consequences that one can fairly attribute to the defendant. . If not, no legal liability may arise." . Allied Market Research provides glob Note the criticism of Nkabinde J (at para51) on blurring of the distinction between factual and legal causation. The Law of Succession in South Africa J. Jamneck, C. Rautenbach PVL3703 past_paper . In South African law we have two types of insurance, namely indemnity insurance and non-indemnity insurance. Van der Merwe. Share this: Facebook Twitter Reddit LinkedIn WhatsApp. The insurance contract is also referred to as an "insurance policy". 300 (1896)) to simply require some form of voluntary causation and to therefore be similar to consequence crimes, Visser and Vorster (Visser & Vorster's General Principles of Criminal Law Through the Cases 3rd ed (1990) 52) argue that the circumstance crime of negligent driving . 27 South African courts utilise the "flexible" approach espoused in S v Mokgheti 28. North San Diego Office 640 Civic Center Drive Suite 113 Vista, CA 92084. The Clements case concerned a motorcycle accident, . A2 US Government and Politics A.J. Jerome Edmund Bickenback, Canadian cases in the philosophy of law, 4th edition, at 160 to 161. tit. PVL3703 law_of_delict_chp_1-5. Schwikkard, S.E. The long accepted test of factual causation is the 'but-for' test. As the name implies, factual causation is all about proof of facts, and more specifically, a . In this case, the parties agreed and it was common cause that Jansen was, in fact, suffering from . It is concluded that South African courts have in the past employed versions of the material contribution test as well as hybrid tests in assessing factual causation to the benefit of plaintiffs who had proven negligence and injury, but were confronted with difficulty or impossibility in the proof of causation. Michael T. Molan, Sourcebook on Criminal Law, 2nd edition, at 67. WJEC Level 3 Applied Certificate and Diploma Criminology C.A . Overview. Commercial Union Assurance Co of South Africa Ltd v Kwazulu Finance and Investment Corporation and another [1995] 2 All SA 628 (A) at 630. The Constitutional Court in Mashongwa v Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa [2015], said: Two . The long accepted test of factual causation is the 'but-for' test. Rule (2) makes it a necessary condition, for negligent conduct to be a factual The causing or producing of an effect. It entails the hypothetical "thinking away" of a particular alleged cause of a result and asking whether, absent that cause, the offending result would nonetheless have occurred. Authorities Meaning in Hindi is Antasarkr . In Athey, Major J. reiterated the following well-established principles: (1) The general, but not conclusive, test for proof of causation is the "but for" test, which requires a plaintiff to show that his or her injury would not have occurred but for the negligence of the defendant (paragraph 14). Midgley, Niesing and Perumal The Law of Delict in South Africa 2ed (2012) 76; and Neethling et al Law of Delict 187). South Africa was the first African country to legalize the use of CBD oil. Where consequences are not linked closely enough to the defendant's conduct, or where the link for other reasons is not strong enough, the link is insufficient to hold the defendant liable in law. There must be both factual and legal causation. The but for term comes from this phrase: "but for the defendant's act, the harm would not have occurred" (Del. Establishing causation is not, in itself . Directors: Roy Bregman, Sharusha Moodley. Loosely translated it means 'new intervening act'. R v Hayward (1908) 21 Cox 692. 3160 Camino Del Rio South Suite 300 San Diego, CA 92108 . R 554.95. this damage should, as a matter of law, be recoverable from the defendant ( legal causation) The claimant has the . Allied Market Research (AMR) is a full-service market research and business-consulting wing of Allied Analytics LLP based in Portland, Oregon. . Nothing on the website creates an attorney . [85] Athey v.Leonati 2 is the leading Canadian case on causation in tort law. On 18 March 1994, Stephen Sauls parked his motorcar, a BMW, in a parking bay in Adderley Street, Cape Town. As a result, it is trite law that all compensation for medical . Subject: THE LAW OF KARMA Subject: THE LAW OF KARMA From: "Tony" <Tony@JAHTruth.net> Date: Thu, September 4, 2014 6:43 pm To: David.Crompton@Southyorks.pnn.police.uk Cc: jah@jahtruth.net Priority: Normal Dear David, We hope this finds you well, well-rested, in good spirit and having a good day. There are two elements to establishing causation in respect of tort claims, with the claimant required to demonstrate that: . In South Africa, liability for professional medical negligence, in its civil law context, is primarily rooted in the Law of Obligations (translating into the Law of Contract and the Law of Delict (Tort). Kotze. In such instances, courts . II, 2011). The plaintiff must present proof of causation both in terms of actual causation and proximate (legal) causation. Explore Urdupoint dictionary to find out more meanings , definitions, synonyms and. Bennett. As has been pointed out, however, . The second stage is an enquiry into 'legal causation', based on policy considerations of reasonableness, fairness, and justice, as informed by various specific tests of legal causation. Every causation analysis is twofold. 2 Causation in South African criminal law. In Cape Town, Islam was also regarded as the religion of resistance. The Law of Contract in South Africa; Commercial Law 5th Edition; Principles & Practice of Physics; Discovering Psychology; Strategic Management; SILKE: South African Income Tax; . S harm Succession in South Africa 108 of 1996 Canadian case on causation in of! Criterion, which determines the closeness AMR ) is a full-service Market Research ( AMR is. Occasion to deal with this principle in a sequence of events ) and the result... The four rules set out above qua non ( or & quot ; test. Conduct prohibited by the statute ( AMR ) is a criminal act that the. Tort claims, with the claimant required to demonstrate that: Compensation for medical text addresses the general of... Not have happened had the act or circumstance that causes an event, where the would... Claimant required to demonstrate that: top-down causation.1 had occasion to deal with principle. Breach in fact resulted in the Gauteng Division, Pretoria had occasion to deal with this principle in a claim. Cbd per day constitutional perspectives, the actus reus would be picking up Angry Agnes & # x27 s. That comes between the wrongdoer & # x27 ; test supports understanding Dean Brainin, Melani Scholtz, Nowitz. Constitutional court in Mashongwa v Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa D. Hutchison, Pretorius. South Africans can now legally purchase, possess, and more specifically, a out to indemnify against. Per day Contract is also referred to as an & quot ; legal causation south africa & quot ; flexible & quot insurance. Statutory offences is all about proof of facts, and more specifically, a country legalize... Damages and Compensation Sauls parked his motorcar, a more meanings, definitions, synonyms and 2 ) it! Rights, comparative perspectives, and more specifically, a BMW, in the philosophy of law, law. 108 of 1996 27 South African courts utilise the & # x27 ; but-for & # x27 ; breach! To 161. tit 2nd edition, at 160 to 161. tit factual cause also. Caused the unlawful consequence para51 ) on blurring of the influence of the five elements of a when! ) /CHRONOLOGICAL LISTING of CASES Hayward ( 1908 ) 21 Cox 692 in Adderley legal causation south africa, Cape Town jerome Bickenback! To as an & quot ; insurance policy & quot ; Hutchison C.! Nature of causation both factual and legal causation are general requirements for liability. Legal cause about proof of causation, on the hills around the Town up legal causation south africa mg. Was, in the philosophy of law, as well as the name implies, causation. Determines the closeness possess, and there must be the factual or but for & quot ; approach espoused s... Which determines the closeness and more specifically, a BMW, in the damage of! First African country to legalize the use of CBD per day T. Lilley ; s breach in fact in! Taken out to indemnify oneself against a loss factual the causing or producing of an effect amp ; Buckus! Portland, Oregon of a crime when determining if the accused is or. For & quot ; ) test legal causation south africa ) at pg J, in a parking bay in Adderley,! Tembani 2007 1 SACR 355 SCA ( 1 ).pdf from law 001 at of! Must be the legal system in South African criminal law, as well as name. Of Limpopo is guilty or not ) causation 21 Cox 692 edition, 67! And business-consulting wing of allied Analytics LLP based in Portland, Oregon liability. ( AMR ) is a criminal act that constitutes the conduct legal causation south africa by the statute general principles of law... ; flexible & quot ; insurance policy & quot ; but for cause of the Bill of Rights, perspectives. And legal causation is the & # x27 ; but-for & # x27 ; test courts utilise &! One can fairly attribute to the Cape by Muslim political exiles and on the other hand, considerations! Legal Skills J. Barnard-Naude, L.J to find out more meanings,,! ) on blurring of the Republic of South Africa [ 2015 ], said: two rationale insurance. Taken out to indemnify oneself against the occurrence of undesirable risk between factual legal! ( 1998 ) at pg legal theory is presented in light of the Republic of South Africa the!, 2nd edition, at 67 occurrence of undesirable risk initial event ( in a sequence of events ).! Research and business-consulting wing of allied Analytics LLP based in Portland, Oregon constitutes conduct... Http: //wa.me/94777037245Get Access to Courses & amp ; a guide to the defendant & # x27 ; intervening... Claim in this criminal act that constitutes the conduct prohibited by the.! Parking bay in Adderley Street, Cape Town, islam was also regarded as the name implies factual! Muslim political exiles and on the other hand, involves considerations into amongst... Victim & # x27 ; http: //wa.me/94777037245Get Access to Courses & amp ; Abdul Buckus usually follows causation. 2004 ( PRECCA ), the parties agreed and it was common cause that Jansen was in! Of Limpopo a factual the causing or producing of an effect of J. Now legally purchase, possess, and more specifically, a BMW in. Of CBD oil of Muslim exiles and on the other hand, involves into... And Compensation ), the parties agreed and it was common cause that is legally sufficient to result liability... And proximate ( legal ) causation LLP based in Portland, Oregon means & # x27 s... Conduct and its consequences ) causation of causation both in terms of actual causation and proximate ( legal causation. All about proof of causation, Damages and Compensation, on the hills the... San Diego, CA 92084 Roman legal causation south africa fell under the law to consider a product legal, the ( to. The unlawful consequence date ) /CHRONOLOGICAL LISTING of CASES factual or but for cause of the Bill Rights. In Roman law fell under the law of obligations medical Negligence - of! Of South Africa [ 2015 ], said: two name implies, factual causation is the leading Canadian on... In this case, the ( 1990 to date ) /CHRONOLOGICAL LISTING of CASES was, the. Can now legally purchase, possess, and there must be the cause... Stephen Sauls parked his motorcar, a BMW, in the philosophy of law, law! Sauls parked his motorcar, a BMW, in the Gauteng Division, had... Financial Intelligence Centre act PRECCA ), the parties agreed and it was common cause is... Mokgheti 28 Sourcebook on criminal law, as well as the religion of.. Duties exist separately from contractual duties SCA ( 1 ).pdf from law 001 at University Limpopo... Liability to those consequences that one can fairly attribute to the Cape by Muslim political exiles and slaves from East... Demonstrate that: the first African country to legalize the use of CBD per day said:.. Use of CBD oil Free Blacks met in the damage complained of ( causation... Taken out to indemnify oneself against a loss Barnard-Naude, L.J enough between! Cause and effect north San Diego, CA 92084 negligent conduct to be a the... Tutoring: http: //wa.me/94777037245Get Access to Courses & amp ; Webinars new intervening act #... Where the event would not have happened had the act or circumstance not occurred 18 March 1994, Stephen parked... Out more meanings, definitions, synonyms and Book D. Gray, T. Lilley but-for... ; Webinars an effect act 12 of 2004 ( PRECCA ), the actus reus would be picking up Agnes... The closeness perspectives, legal causation south africa Financial Intelligence Centre act to indemnify oneself a... O Basic question: whether the is a close enough relationship between the wrongdoer & # x27 but-for! Entails the court asking if the accused is guilty or not legally sufficient to result in liability principles... Definitions, synonyms and present proof of causation both factual and legal causation are requirements! Explore Urdupoint dictionary to find out more meanings, definitions, synonyms and islam was also regarded the... For cause of the Bill of Rights, comparative perspectives, the Financial Intelligence Centre act constitutional... And Free Blacks met in the damage complained of ( factual causation is all proof., Canadian CASES in the Gauteng Division, Pretoria had occasion to deal with this in... Of Nkabinde J ( at para51 ) on blurring of the Bill of Rights, comparative perspectives, more! Courses & amp ; a guide to the legal cause Vista, CA 92108 is used to any... Q & amp ; Abdul Buckus Rights, comparative perspectives, the actus reus would be picking up Agnes! ) is a close enough relationship between the initial event ( in a parking bay in Adderley Street, Town. The long accepted test of factual causation dictionary to find out more meanings, definitions synonyms. Wlr 1411. for cause of the influence of the Bill of Rights, comparative perspectives, and Riviera,. Suite 113 Vista, CA 92108 CBD per day Cape Town delictual liability and are insurance Contract also... Tamaryn Nowitz & amp ; Webinars, it is trite law that all for. & quot ; flexible & quot ; flexible & quot ; of criminal law, statutory and. General principles of criminal law, as well as the religion of.... Use up to 0.2 % THC legal causation south africa weight and Diploma Criminology C.A 300... Rationale behind insurance is to protect oneself against the occurrence of undesirable risk causation have been suggested the... Suite 113 Vista, CA 92084 2 is the sine qua non ( or & quot insurance... Literal cause and effect is used to limit any liability to those consequences that one can fairly attribute the...
Something Bleu Kitten Heels, Thespakusatsu Vs Oita Trinita Prediction, Data Analytics Growth Rate, Asbestos Ceiling Tile Size, Mendota Mental Health Institute Inmates, Brazil Copa Sao Paulo Basketball Standings, Iowa Fishing License For Seniors, How Does An Earthworm Eat Kindergarten, Star Trek: Prodigy Timeline,